Tradies & Contractors

CIS Subcontractor Records: A Checklist from Payment to Year-End

Learn how to separate materials from labour, check monthly CIS statements against bank receipts, and resolve missing deductions before year-end.

For subcontractors paid under deduction, the paperwork needs to explain every pound withheld.

What CIS subcontractor records do I need to reconcile deductions at year-end? Keep your invoices, evidence of materials costs, contractor payment and deduction statements, and bank receipts, linked so each payment can be traced from the gross amount to the deduction and net cash received.

A bank credit proves what arrived, not what the contractor withheld. An invoice proves what you charged, not what they paid. The monthly statement connects those figures, which is why a missing statement can turn an expected refund into a prolonged evidence query.

This checklist follows the work from setting up a contractor through to the year-end handover. It describes record-keeping practice, not tax advice; check HMRC’s subcontractor guidance for the rules affecting your business.

1. Give each contractor a place in your CIS records

  • Create a contractor record before the first invoice. Save their legal business name, accounts contact, your subcontractor account number, and the name and UTR under which they have verified you. Keep sensitive identifiers in a restricted folder, not a sheet shared with everyone on site.

A trading name is not always the company paying you. If “Oakfield Projects” appears on the site boards but Oakfield Construction Ltd issues the statements, record both names. Otherwise, a bank transfer from a third name can look like an unexplained payment.

Set up three spreadsheet tabs:

  • Invoices: invoice number, contractor, job, invoice date, labour, materials charged, VAT, total and invoice link.
  • CIS payments: payment date, contractor, invoice allocation, tax month ending, gross payment excluding VAT, materials allowed in the CIS calculation, deduction rate, deduction, net bank receipt and statement link.
  • Materials evidence: purchase date, supplier, receipt number, job, cost, VAT and image link.

Keep one payment row per payment, not automatically one per invoice. Contractors often pay several invoices together or settle one invoice in instalments.

Business structure matters. Sole traders normally account for CIS deductions through Self Assessment; limited companies use a different process involving their PAYE scheme. Do not place company deductions into a director’s personal return. Flag your structure clearly for whoever prepares the reconciliation.

2. Capture materials evidence before raising the invoice

  • Attach materials purchases to the job while the details are still obvious. Record the supplier invoice or receipt, what was bought, its cost and the job reference. Keep delivery notes where they explain which site received the goods.

For CIS, materials are not simply whatever you label “materials” on your sales invoice. The contractor needs the qualifying direct cost you actually incurred. A markup does not become deductible from the CIS calculation just because it sits on the materials line.

Your VAT position also matters: HMRC’s calculation excludes recoverable VAT from materials costs for VAT-registered subcontractors, while a non-VAT-registered subcontractor’s materials cost includes VAT. Keep the original VAT breakdown rather than overwriting it with a single adjusted figure.

A £288 Screwfix receipt covering two sites needs an allocation, not two copies each claiming £288. Record the items assigned to each job. If you return £48 of fittings next week, link the credit note and update the job cost.

Scan2Sheet fits this capture step: it extracts receipt data into your own Google Sheet and links each row to a cloud-stored image. Review the extracted figures and categorisation, use duplicate detection when a receipt has been photographed twice, and capture every section of a long receipt; you still need to add the job allocation.

3. Separate labour, materials charged and actual materials cost

  • Show labour and materials separately on the invoice, with VAT separately where applicable. Where the materials charge includes a markup, provide a supporting breakdown of actual cost for the contractor’s CIS calculation.

One line saying “works completed: £2,750” leaves accounts staff guessing. It can lead to a deduction on the whole amount while you spend weeks trying to recover the difference.

Worked example: materials sold above cost

Priya, a non-VAT-registered subcontractor, invoices Oakfield Construction Ltd on 12 May 2026:

Invoice OC-118 lineAmount
Labour: bathroom installation£2,000
Materials supplied£750
Total invoice£2,750

Her linked supplier receipts show actual materials costs of £600 including VAT. Assuming those costs qualify and the contractor applies a 20% deduction:

  • CIS deduction base: £2,750 − £600 = £2,150.
  • CIS withheld: £2,150 × 20% = £430.
  • Bank payment: £2,750 − £430 = £2,320.

The deduction base exceeds the labour line because it includes the £150 materials markup. Subtracting the £750 selling price would produce a £400 deduction instead: a £30 discrepancy.

Do not force your spreadsheet to agree with an incorrect calculation. Send the contractor the cost evidence and request a checked calculation and, where necessary, corrected paperwork. HMRC’s CIS contractor guidance explains how deductions are calculated.

4. Match each bank payment before filing its statement

  • Allocate the cash received to the invoice or invoices it settles. Use the remittance advice where available. Record the actual payment date, not just the invoice date.

For Priya’s payment on 22 May, the payment tab would contain:

Payment dateInvoiceTax month endingGross excluding VATMaterials costCIS withheldBank receipt
22 May 2026OC-1185 June 2026£2,750£600£430£2,320

A CIS tax month runs from the 6th to the following 5th, not from the first to the last calendar day.

Contrast Priya’s materials-heavy invoice with Ben’s labour-only £1,800 invoice. At 20%, Ben expects £360 withheld and £1,440 received. If payment is made on 6 April 2026, it belongs in the CIS month ending 5 May 2026 and the 2026/27 deduction reconciliation—even if the invoice was dated 28 March. Keep invoice and payment dates separate; accounting treatment of the income may depend on the accounting basis used.

If the bank credit is short for another reason, identify it separately. A retention, contra-charge or withheld disputed amount is not automatically CIS tax. Obtain the contractor’s breakdown rather than recording every missing pound as a deduction.

5. Check the monthly payment and deduction statement

  • Check the statement’s identity fields and totals before marking the month complete. A remittance headed “payment advice” is not sufficient if it omits the required CIS particulars.

For payments made under deduction, the statement should show:

  • The contractor’s name and employer tax reference.
  • Your name and UTR.
  • The tax month ending date, or relevant payment date where statements are issued for individual payments.
  • Gross payments excluding VAT.
  • The materials amount used in calculating deductions.
  • The CIS deduction amount.
  • The verification reference number where the higher deduction rate applies.

A statement may cover one payment or aggregate payments within the tax month. For a monthly total, add the underlying payment rows and compare them with the statement; do not enter the monthly statement as another payment and double-count it.

Check your name and UTR particularly carefully after incorporation, a partnership change or a contractor account migration. Correct amounts against the wrong entity still create a reconciliation problem.

A 30% deduction when you expected 20% needs an immediate query about verification details and status. Do not edit it down to your expected rate. Record what was actually withheld and retain any subsequent correction.

6. Chase missing statements on the 20th, not in January

  • Set a recurring statement check for the 20th of each month. Contractors must provide statements within 14 days of the end of the relevant tax month—normally by the 19th.

For payments between 6 May and 5 June 2026, the statement is due by 19 June 2026. On 20 June, filter the payment tab for that tax month and blank statement links.

Send a request that accounts staff can action:

Please send the CIS payment and deduction statement for the tax month ending 5 June 2026. Our records show invoice OC-118, paid 22 May: gross £2,750, materials cost £600, CIS deducted £430, net received £2,320. Please confirm any difference in your calculation.

Keep the request and response with the payment record. If nothing arrives, follow up with the accounts manager and retain a dated chase log. Use a status such as Requested 20/06, Received, or Correction pending; a blank cell does not tell you whether anyone has acted.

For a month with no payment, do not manufacture a missing-statement problem. The control is statements against payments made under deduction, not twelve documents from every contractor regardless of activity.

7. Resolve evidence gaps before preparing a refund claim

  • After 5 April, total deductions by contractor and match each total to statements. Then reconcile those payments to the bank and investigate every unresolved difference.

Suppose Ben’s payment records suggest £7,920 withheld across the year, but his saved statements support only £6,480. The £1,440 gap is not fixed by entering the larger number into his return. His bank credits alone cannot establish whether the shortfalls were CIS, retention or disputed work.

Ask the contractor for duplicate statements first. If they have ceased trading or will not respond, preserve invoices, bank records, remittances and chase correspondence, then contact HMRC using its subcontractor guidance for missing statements. Do not create replacement statements yourself or assume unsupported deductions will be accepted.

An incomplete pack does not automatically mean a refund is refused. It makes the amount harder to substantiate, particularly if your figures differ from the contractor’s CIS returns. What should have been a reconciliation can become a dispute over what was actually withheld.

Keep reported deductions separate from any expected refund. CIS withheld is a payment towards tax liabilities, not a promise that the whole amount will come back.

8. Lock down the CIS handover and retention dates

  • Export the reconciled workbook and save its evidence alongside it. Include statements, invoices, materials receipts, bank records and a short unresolved-items list. Check that image links still work for the person receiving the pack.

For 2025/26, the usual Self Assessment deadlines are 31 October 2026 for paper returns and 31 January 2027 online. Self-employed records normally need retaining for at least five years after the relevant 31 January submission deadline: ordinarily until at least 31 January 2032 for that year. Late returns, enquiries and company records can require different retention periods; check HMRC’s record-keeping guidance.

If Making Tax Digital for Income Tax applies to you, confirm the compatible-software workflow with your accountant. A receipt spreadsheet and annual reconciliation do not, by themselves, satisfy digital reporting requirements.

Start with your latest CIS payment and build its evidence trail backwards. Use Scan2Sheet to capture the materials receipts, then link the invoice, bank payment and contractor statement.